Macroeconomics:
Recession Indicators:
Leading Indicators | Coincident Indicators | Lagging Indicators |
---|---|---|
Bond Yields | GDP | Interest Rates/Prime Rates |
Layoff Rates | Non-Farm Payrolls | Unemployment Rate |
Manufacturing Activity | Sales/Income/Spending | Corporate Profits |
Stock Markets |
Customer Accounts:
Various Disclosure/Agreement Documents:
New Account Form:
- Script used in telemarketing is retail communication - Approval required by a principal before first use
- Obtain all necessary information from the customer prior to account opening (Patriot Act)
- Account has to be approved by a designated principal
- After, the account is opened a firm has 30 days to send the information back to the customer for verification
Margin Agreement:
- When: Customers must sign and return to their brokers before they begin trading
- What: Hypothecation Agreement, Credit Agreement, Loan Consent Form (Optional)
Margin Disclosure Agreement:
- When: Prior or at the time of opening an account, and annually thereafter
- What: General Info and risks of a Margin Account
Options Agreement:
- When: Must sign within 15 days of account approval
- What: It has positions limits/allowable options which a customer can take
Options Disclosure Document:
- When: At or before a registered options principal approves the account
- What: It has been prepared by the OCC for general info/risks of Options
Discretionary Accounts:
- Principal must approve the account, and approve each discretionary trade promptly after execution
DVP vs RVP:
- Delivery vs Payment: Pay money before or at the same time as securities are delivered
- Receipt vs Payment: Pay money before securities are delivered
Broker Check Disclosures:
- BDs must provide customers annually Broker-Check website address and info + description of content that customers can access there
Titling Accounts:
- Individual Accounts
- Joint Accounts
- JTIC
- JTWROS
- Fiduciary Accounts
- Trust Account
- Revocable: May be cancelled as the trustor pleases
- Irrevocable: Can’t be cancelled without the approval of the beneficiary
- Business Accounts:
- Corporate Account
- Partnership Account (Investment Clubs)
Customer Account Maintenance:
Account Statements:
- Send Quarterly statements, if there is:
- Security Position
- Money Balance
- Any account activity since last statement
- Send Monthly statement, if there is:
- Active Account: Purchases, sales, interest or dividends, or any funds flowing in or out of the account.
- Account has penny stocks or Options
Trade Confirmations
- When: At or before settlement
- What: Apart from trade details:
- Inform if the broker acted as a broker or a dealer
- Any control relationship b/w securities issuer and the broker
Munis Confirmations:
- Inform Yield to Worst (lower of YTC or YTM)
Customer Mail:
- Broker can hold for 3 months, provided customer gives a written request
- More than 3 months, customer should give a proper reason: such as security/safety - convenience can’t be a reason
Customer Account Protection:
Reg S-P:
- Privacy Notice: Provided at account opening and annually thereafter
- Commingling of securities of broker and customer securities is not allowed
Protection of Vulnerable Investors:
- Who is Vulnerable?
- Age 65>=
- Age 18>= and have a mental/physical impairment that renders them unable to protect their interests
- How to Protect?
- Obtain name and contact of a trusted contact
- Can place temporary hold on distribution of funds/securities if broker suspects exploitation
- Initially for 15 days
- Then can extend by 10 days if suspicion persists
- Additional 30 days if the BD has reported the incident to regulator/agency/court
Tax-Advantaged Accounts:
1. Retirement Accounts:
1.1 Corporate Retirement Accounts:
Qualified (ERISA Compliant)
- Benefit: Eligible for pre-tax contribution and investments grow tax-deferred. Completely taxed at withdrawal
- Eligibility:
- Must be offered to all full-time employees age 21>=, with 1+ year with company
- Part time employees: 500 hrs>= in 3 consecutive years
- Should have a vesting schedule (must be 100% vested post Year 5)
- Types:
- Defined Benefit: simply called by a generic name - Pension Plan
- Defined Contribution Names:
- Employers can do matching contribution and/or profit sharing
- 401(k): Private Companies. Pre-tax contribution -> Tax-Deferred Growth -> Entirely taxable at withdrawal. RMD required post 73
- 403(b): Education Institutions/NFPs/Charities. 401(k) by another name.
- 457(b): Government Agencies and Charities. 401(k) by another name.
Other Qualified Defined Contribution Plans:
- Roth 401(k):
- After-Tax contribution -> Tax-Deferred Growth -> Tax-Free Withdrawal
- Only employees contribution goes in the account, and not the employers. Employer can contribute to only regular 401(k)
- Account must be atleast 5 years old, and age>=59.5 for withdrawals
- Keogh Plans or HR-10 Plans:
- Available to only sef-employed people
- SEP-IRA = Simplified Employee Pension Plan
- Offered by small businesses
- Only employer can contribute but the contributions are optional
- SIMPLE IRA = Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees
- No. of Employees <=100
- Both Employees and Employer can contribute
- Employer contributions are mandatory
Non-Qualified (Non ERISA Compliant)
- After-tax contribution -> Tax-Deferred Growth -> Tax only on the growth portion (as contributions were already taxed ab-initio)
- Types:
- Deferred Compensation
- Payroll Deduction
1.2 Individual Retirement Accounts:
Traditional IRAs
- Characteristics:
- No Minimum Age. Only earned income can be contributed
- Max (USD 7,000, 100% annual earned income) a year contribution. 50=+ people can contribute USD 1000 extra (called catch-up contribution)
- If contributions limit breached -> 6% penalty on excess amount
- Can create a Spousal IRA with same benefits
- These accounts are always individual, and never held jointly
- Some investments prohibited in IRAs: Fixed life insurance, antiques, risky options like uncovered calls, and real estate
- Distributions:
- Allowed after 59.5=> age; Also RMDs (Required Minimum Distributions) from Apr 1 of the year following, a person turns 73
- Withdraw before 59.5 => 10% Penalty. Exceptions:
- Medical Reasons: Death/Disability/Terminally Ill/Medical Expenses
- Education and kids: Education Expense of self/spouse/children/grand-children; Birth/Adopting a kid (limited to USD 5000 / per parent)
- House and Disaster Area: First-time homebuyers (upto 10k); living in federal declared disaster areas (upto 22k)
- No withdrawal after 73.5 => 25% excise tax on under-distributed amount. Excise tax reduced to 10% if the under-distributed amount is fixed in next 2 years
Roth IRAs
- Only available to people who earn below a certain income level
- If an individual has multiple IRAs, then the contribution limits apply to all IRAs in aggregate
Rollover:
- Moving from IRA to another IRA within 60 days => avoid any tax consequences
2. Annuities
Annuity Periods:
- Accumulation Period
- Annuitization Period
Fixed Annuity:
- Contributions go into the General Account of the insurer for investment
Variable Annuity:
- Contributions go into the Separate Account of the insurer for investment. This is because, the investment has to be made according to the choice of the investor
Payout Options:
- Straight Life: Highest monthly payment
- Life with Period Certain: Payment guaranteed for certain period
- Joint with last survivor: Lowest monthly payment
1035 Exchange:
- Moving from Annuity to another => avoid any tax consequences
- However, surrender charges from the insurer may still apply
3. Education and Individuals with Disability
529 College Savings Plan:
- Established and maintained by the states. Therefore, are technically -> munis (municipal fund securities), and subject to MSRB
- Must provide Program Disclosure Document
- Operates similar to Roth IRA vis-a-vis tax, but no tax on distribution. Although, states may take their own taxes on distribution if they wish
- However, no requirement to contribute earned income, unlike IRAs
- Distribution only for qualified education expenses
- Can be opened for anyone - minors/adults/self/kids
- If the beneficiary doesn’t want to use the funds, can transfer the funds to 529 of another family member without penalty. Allowed once per year
- If withdrawal not for qualified education expenses, then a penalty of 10%
Coverdell Education Savings Account:
- Similar to 529 above, but not a muni
- Tax wise works exactly as Roth IRA/529 CSP
- Contributions are limited to USD 2,000 per year per beneficiary
- Only available to families below a certain income level
- Can be opened for any student <= 18, and funds must be disbursed before 30. (No such restrictions in 529)
- Funds can be transferred to Coverdell of any other family member
- Much less popular than 529 because of all these restrictions
ABLE Accounts
- Tax wise similar to Roth IRA/529/Coverdell
- Can be opened by individuals who have a disability prior to age 26
- Qualified Expenses: Education/Housing/Transportation/Employment Training/Health
Registrations
1. BD Registration:
- All BDs must register with SEC aka FINRA => Form BD + New Member Agreement + Business Plan + Fees
- Registration with SEC means “Authorization” to do securities business, and doesn’t mean Approval/Endorsement by SEC/FINRA
2. Agent Registration:
U4:
- U4 for all agent + Fingerprints + Fees
- 5 years of residential history + 10 years of employment history + Education background + SSN + Name
- Fingerprints are required within 30 days of filing a U4
- Maintain records of people who have left the company for atleast three years
- Regular U4 updates required in 30 days, but reportable event (leading to statutory disqualification) should be reported in 10 days
U5:
- Reason for termination should be there
- Must file within 30 days of termination
- Unregistered people subject to 2 years of regulatory jurisdiction (rep to update addresses in this 2 year period)
Qualification Exams:
- If left the industry for 2+ years, retake the appropriate exam
- If left the industry for 4+ years, retake SIE too in addition to above (SIE is valid for 4 years)
FinPro’s MQP (Maintaining Qualification Program):
- Within 2 years of leaving the firm, enroll in FinPro’s MQP Program
- Complete annual training and pay USD 100 annual fee
- Max five years (2+3), beyond that if an individual returns => need to retake the exams
Statutory Disqualification:
- Criminal:
- Any felony conviction in past 10 years
- Securities related misdemeanor conviction in past 10 years
- Injunction (temp/permanent) issued by a court
- Regulatory:
- Expulsion/Suspension from a SRO/regulator
- Findings of falsifications in filings to SROs/regulators or wilful violation of securities laws
Continuing Education:
- Regulatory Element:
- When: By Dec 31
- Who: All registered persons
- Firm Element by Dec 31
- When: By Dec 31
- Who: All covered persons - who interact with customers/supervise those who interact with customers
- Failure to comply with Regulatory Element may result in CE Inactive Status, while the same is not true for Firm Element
Wrap Accounts:
- If a BD provided a Wrap Account, BD needs to register as a RIA too
3. RIA (Registered Investment Advisors)
ABC Test
- Provides Advice
- As a Business
- For Compensation
- Subject to Fiduciary Standard. Agents of BDs to Suitability/Best Interest Standards
Registration:
- From ADV
4. IAR (Investment Advisor Representatives)
General Info
- Need to register at the state level only, while RIAs register at Federal/State level depending on size
Exceptions from being an IAR:
- LATE (Lawyers, Accountants, Teachers, & Engineers) are not IARs if they provide advice as incidental to their job
- Family office advisors who provide advise to clients of only one family
- Banks and BHCs
- Newspaper publishers
- BDs and their Agents provided they are not providing a Wrap Account
Business Conduct:
Insider Trading:
- Misappropriation Theory: Stealing info and trading on any company’s stock not just own company
- Penalties: Both Tipper and Tippee are liable. Treble (3 times) damages (Gain made or losses avoided). 20 year jail and/or USD 5mm penalty
- Duty of Trust: Recipient should have knows that MNPI (material non-public information) is being shared
Prevention Mechanisms:
- Information barriers between private side and public side (trading/research)
- Restricted List: List of securities in which Prop + Employee + Solicited Customer Transactions can’t be done
- Watch List: No restrictions but any trading in these securities is closely monitored by the compliance department
Anti-Money Laundering:
Three stages of Money Laundering:
- Placement: Depositing money in the system. It is the easiest stage to detect
- Layering: Performing a series of transactions to launder the money
- Integration: Withdrawing and reintegrating the money into the system
FinCEN (Financial Crimes Enforcement Network):
- Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) enacted in 1970, lays the framework for AML
- FinCEN, a bureau within the treasury administers BSA
- IRS and OCC (other bureaus in Treasury) further assist in AML
Currency Transaction Report (CTR):
- Cash/Traveler’s Check/Cashier’s Check/Money Order totalling more than USD 10,000 in one day => File a CTR with FinCEN within 15 days
- Inform the customer that CTR has been filed
Suspicious Activity Report (SAR):
- Filed by BD to FinCEN within 30 days if BD suspects money laundering by customer. Ex: Depositing just under USD 10,000
- Customer should not be informed that an SAR has been filed
USA Patriot Act: (Enacted in 2001 and strengthened the BSA)
AML Compliance Program:
- All BDs must have
- Give the AML compliance officer’s name/contact info to FINRA. Doesn’t need to be a registered representative
- Audit the AML program annually by an independent III party within/outside the firm
Customer Identification Program:
- All BDs must have
- Obtain identity info of every customer before opening an account
- Verify the identity within a reasonable time frame before or after opening an account
l
SDN (Specially Designated Nationals) List:
- Compiled by OFAC (Office of Foreign Asset Control), an office in the Treasury.
- Can’t transact with anyone on SDN. Block the transaction and report to OFAC within 10 days
- Mandatory information sharing with federal law enforcement
Opening a trading account at another BD:
- Approval needed from employer before opening an account
- Notify the other BD that you are a registered agent of your firm before opening an account
- If changing firms, and need to continue your account at this other BD, obtain approval from new employer within 30 days
- Immediate Family Members too bound by this rule. However, it can be waived off if the rep proves that no financial benefit/control exists
- Exceptions: Above rules don’t apply if the account is for only mutual funds/UITs/or variable annuities
Payment to Unregistered Persons:
- Not allowed
Continuing Commissions:
- Written Contract prior to leaving the job
- Can’t be engaged in any securities related activities to continue receiving commissions
Outside Business Activity (OBA):
- OBA = Outside Activity for which rep receives compensation. Even if rep starts a business, but doesn’t pay himself a salary, it is a OBA. Notify Employer
- Update Form U4
Private Securities Transactions:
- Compensation received: Prior approval of firm is needed, else it is “Selling Away” - a violation. If approved, the transaction must be recorded on the firm’s books, and supervised
- **Compensation not received: Notify employer
Gifts:
- USD 100 per year per person limit
- Above rule doesn’t apply to entertainment expenses, provided the Rep also attends
Sharing in customer accounts:
- Not permitted generally
- Permitted only if:
- Permission from both employer and the customer
- Sharing is proportionate to money contributed by the agent and the customer
- Accounts with family members are not subject to proportionate sharing
- Reps can’t be Beneficiary/Executor/Trustee/Power of Attorney (POA) holder on behalf of a customer, except when the customer is a family member
Borrowing/Lending from Customers:
- Generally prohibited, but allowed if the employer’s rules permit and only limited to following:
- Family Members
- Banks (other financial institutions engaged in that activity)
- Personal/Business relationship outside the broker/customer relationship
- Firm’s written pre-approval required for case iii above and also if borrowing/lending from banks is not on standard commercial terms. In other words, borrow/lend from family members and from banks on standard commercial terms doesn’t require pre-approval. It is just that the companies rules should allow it.
Customer Complaints:
Written Complaint:
- Record must be kept no matter what of complaint + action taken
- Must be forwarded to the principal
- Report to FINRA by 15th of the month after the quarter in which complaint was received
Verbal Complaint:
- Don’t need to forward to the principal
MSRB Investor Brochure:
- Summarizes kep principles of the MSRB’s customer protection rules and provides a link to the MSRB rulebook
Conflict of Interest:
- Verbal Disclosure: Prior to the trade
- Written Disclosure: Must appear on trade confirmation
Political Contributions:
Pay to Play in Munis:
- Municipal Finance Professionals (MFPs) at a Muni BD:
- Sales
- Trading
- Underwriting
- Research
- MFPs don’t include people involved in retail sales
- Records of MFPs and any political contributions should be maintained for 6 years
- If contributed, ban of 2 years on negotiated deals with the muni issuer
- Can contribute upto USD 250 if one is a voter for that candidate
- Contributions by spouses of MFPs are not subject to the USD 250 limit, unless the donation was directed by the MFP
Communication for BDs:
Retail Communication:
- > 25 retail investors over a 30 day period. Written/Electronic communication distributed/made available
- Purely verbal communication is not considered a communication with the public
- Principal approval required prior to first use
- Must maintain records of retail communication and approvals for 3 years
- Not permitted: Can’t project future performance/ or imply past performance predicts future results
- Permitted: Hypothetical illustration of mathematical principles. A price target but only if it is part of a research report
Correspondence Communication:
- <= 25 retail investors over a 30 day period. Written/Electronic communication distributed/made available
- Supervision and spot-checks by Principal
Institutional Communication:
- Any count of institutional investors but zero retail investors Written/Electronic communication distributed/made available
- Supervision and spot-checks by Principal
Social Media:
Static Content:
- Permanent content posted on Website/FB/Insta etc.
- Treated as retail communication -> prior principal approval necessary
Interactive Content:
- Transient/real-time content -> tweets/responses/comments
- Only supervision and spot checks by the principal
Personal Email:
- Agent can speak with client over personal email, provided prior approval by employer and the communication is monitored by the firm
MSRB Communication Rules:
- Same rules as FINRA’s for BDs but Retail Communication is labeled as advertisement, and the time period is 90 days instead of 30 days. The threshold of 25 retail investors is same.
- Record maintenance is for 4 years for MSRB (FINRA one is 3 years)
- Also MSRB doesn’t controls issuers, so its guidelines are applicable to only communication originated by muni BDs and not to communication by issuers.
Business Continuity Plans (BCPs):
- Give customers a summary of the BCP at account opening
- Plan’s summary should be on the website
- Provide customer’s a copy of the summary should they need one
- Designate two people as emergency contacts (one must be senior management and a registered principal)
- Emergency contacts should be reported to FINRA, and any changes must be updated in 30 days
Securities:
Exempt Securities:
- US Govt./Agencies/Munis
- NFPs
- Commercial Banks only (Not BHCs or Investment Banks)
- Commercial Paper with maturity < 270 days
Exempt Transactions:
Intrastate Offerings: Rule 147
- Principal place of business in the state + Any one below
- 80% of Revenue within the state
- 80% of Assets within the state
- 80% of Proceeds to be used within the state
- A majority of employees within the state
Equity Securities:
- Statutory Voting vs Cumulative Voting
- Ex-Dividend Date: On or After Date - if shared purchased, buyer receives no dividend
- Record Date: Last date on which the name of the person should be on the list of shareholders to receive the dividend. If trades settle T+1 (Regular settlement), Ex-dividend date = Record Date
- Penny Stock: An unlisted stock trading for less than USD 5 per share
- Preferred Stock Types:
- Straight Preferred Stock: Vanilla kind
- Cumulative Preferred Stock: Dividends accumulate if not paid
- Participating Preferred Stock: Eligible to receive extra dividends
- Convertible Preferred Stock: Can be converted to common stock
- Callable Preferred: Can be called by the issuer
- Adjustable-rate Preferred: Dividend rate is based on a benchmark
- All order memorandums (order ticket) must be approved by a supervisor promptly after order execution
Media Compensation:
Three exceptions:
- Paid Advertising
- Research Reports
- Compensation clearly disclosed as to specified amount
Time-in-Force (TIF) Order Types
Order Type | Abbreviation | Duration / Condition |
---|---|---|
Day Order | — | Valid for the trading day only; default if no TIF specified |
Good-Til-Canceled | GTC | Stays active until executed or manually canceled (often expires after 90 days) |
Good-Til-Date | GTD | Remains active until a specific date set by the investor |
Immediate-or-Cancel | IOC | Must be executed immediately, fully or partially; remainder is canceled |
Fill-or-Kill | FOK | Must be completely filled immediately, or the entire order is canceled |
At-the-Open | — | Executes only at market open; canceled if not filled at the open |
At-the-Close | — | Executes only at market close; canceled if not filled at the close |
Markets:
- Primary Market: IPO
- Secondary Market: Stock Exchanges
- Third Market: OTC
- Fourth Market: Electronic Communication Networks (ECNs)
Debt Securities:
- EMMA (Electronic Municipal Market Access): Public online resource operated by MSRB - can be used by investors for research
Accrued Interest:
- Seller’s share: Previous Coupon Date to Settlement Date (with the settlement day excluded)
- Bonds that are in default or are Zero Coupon: trade flat => no accrued interest
Accrued Interest Day Count Convention:
- Corporate + Munis + Agency: 30/360
- T-Notes and T-Bonds: Actual/365
- T Bill: Actual/360
Quoting T-Notes and Bonds:
- 1/32th of a point, and quoted as percentage of par
Quoting T-Bills:
- Discounted Yield Basis, with the discount expressed as an annual rate based on a 360-day year
- Bid Quotes are greater than Ask Quotes over here
Extra Notes:
Major Regulations for the SIE Exam
Regulation | Description | Regulatory Authority |
---|---|---|
Regulation T (Reg T) | Sets initial margin requirements (typically 50%) for buying securities on credit. Also governs the use of credit in margin accounts. | Federal Reserve Board |
Regulation U (Reg U) | Governs how banks can extend credit for the purchase of margin securities. | Federal Reserve Board |
Regulation X (Reg X) | Requires borrowers (customers) to comply with Reg T and U if they obtain credit from foreign lenders to buy securities. | Federal Reserve Board |
Regulation D (Reg D) | Provides exemptions from SEC registration for private placements of securities under specific conditions (e.g., Rule 506). | SEC |
Regulation A (Reg A) | Allows small and mid-sized companies to raise capital with limited SEC registration (Tier 1 and Tier 2 offerings). | SEC |
Regulation M (Reg M) | Prohibits market manipulation during public offerings (e.g., underwriters cannot bid up prices during the restricted period). | SEC |
Regulation FD (Reg FD) | Promotes full and fair disclosure by requiring public dissemination of material nonpublic information. | SEC |
Regulation S-P (Reg S-P) | Requires firms to protect customers’ personal financial information and provide privacy notices. | SEC |
Regulation S-ID (Reg S-ID) | Requires broker-dealers and investment advisers to implement identity theft prevention programs (“Red Flag Rules”). | SEC |
Regulation SHO (Reg SHO) | Governs short selling and requires firms to locate securities before executing short sales. | SEC |
Issued Stock vs. Outstanding Stock: Key Differences
Category | Issued Stock | Outstanding Stock |
---|---|---|
Definition | Total number of shares a company has ever sold (includes both outstanding shares and treasury stock). | Total number of shares held by investors (excludes treasury stock). |
Includes Treasury Stock? | Yes, includes both shares held by investors and repurchased shares (treasury stock). | No, excludes treasury stock since those shares are held by the company itself. |
Held by Investors? | Not necessarily—some issued shares may be repurchased by the company and held as treasury stock. | Yes, outstanding stock consists only of shares that are currently in the hands of investors. |
Used to Calculate EPS? | No, issued stock is not used for EPS calculations. | Yes, outstanding stock is used in EPS (Earnings Per Share) calculations. |
Can Change Over Time? | Yes, if the company issues new shares or buys back shares. | Yes, when companies issue new shares or repurchase shares. |
Formula Relationship
Issued Stock = Outstanding Stock + Treasury Stock
Example
- A company initially issues 1,000,000 shares.
- Over time, it buys back 200,000 shares, which become treasury stock.
- The outstanding shares now equal 800,000.
Thus:
1,000,000 (Issued Stock) = 800,000 (Outstanding Stock) + 200,000 (Treasury Stock)
Statutory Voting vs. Cumulative Voting
Feature | Statutory Voting | Cumulative Voting |
---|---|---|
Definition | A shareholder must vote the same number of shares for each board seat available. | A shareholder can allocate their total votes freely among one or more candidates. |
Formula for Total Votes | Shares Owned × Number of Seats Available | Shares Owned × Number of Seats Available (same as statutory voting) |
Voting Flexibility | Less flexible—votes must be split evenly across all candidates. | More flexible—votes can be concentrated on one or a few candidates. |
Effect on Minority Shareholders | Less favorable—majority shareholders have stronger control over the board. | More favorable—allows minority shareholders to increase their influence by pooling votes on specific candidates. |
Common Use Case | More common in large corporations where majority shareholders prefer control. | Often used in companies where protecting minority shareholders is a priority. |
Example | If a shareholder owns 1,000 shares and there are 3 board seats, they can cast 1,000 votes per seat. | If a shareholder owns 1,000 shares and there are 3 board seats, they have 3,000 total votes and can distribute them as they wish (e.g., all 3,000 votes to one candidate). |
Key Takeaways
- Statutory voting benefits majority shareholders, ensuring their preferred candidates win.
- Cumulative voting benefits minority shareholders, giving them a chance to elect at least one board member.
Board Elections: Typical Frequency, Board Size, and Candidate Contests
The number of candidates per board seat, the frequency of elections, and board size vary depending on company size and governance practices.
1. Board Elections Frequency
- Most common: Annual elections (though some companies have staggered terms).
- Staggered (Classified) Boards: Some companies elect one-third of the board every year to prevent hostile takeovers.
2. Board Size & Number of Candidates per Seat (Large Cap vs. Mid-Market vs. Small Cap)
Company Size | Typical Board Size | Number of Candidates per Seat | Election Frequency |
---|---|---|---|
Large-Cap (S&P 500 firms) | 9 - 15 directors | Usually 1-2 per seat (often unopposed) | Annual or staggered (every 3 years for a third of the board) |
Mid-Market ($500M - $5B valuation) | 7 - 11 directors | Usually 1-3 per seat (depends on activist investors) | Annual or staggered |
Small-Cap (< $500M valuation) | 5 - 9 directors | 1-5 per seat (sometimes competitive, especially in contested elections) | Annual |
3. Candidate Contests: How Many People Run for a Seat?
- Most common: 1 candidate per seat (the board nominates a candidate who is usually elected uncontested).
- In contested elections: 2-5 candidates per seat, especially when activist investors push for board changes.
- Hostile Takeover/Proxy Fight: Can have multiple candidates per seat (e.g., activist hedge funds nominate their own directors to challenge management).
4. Real-World Examples
Large-Cap Example: Apple Inc. (AAPL)
- Board size: 8-12 members.
- Election frequency: Annual elections.
- Candidates per seat: Typically one nominee per seat (low competition).
- Voting type: Statutory voting.
Mid-Market Example: Dick’s Sporting Goods (DKS)
- Board size: 7-10 members.
- Election frequency: Annual or staggered.
- Candidates per seat: Usually 1-2 per seat, but can increase in activist-driven cases.
Small-Cap Example: A Startup-turned-Public Company (e.g., Etsy in its early public years)
- Board size: 5-9 members.
- Election frequency: Annual.
- Candidates per seat: 1-5 (more competition, more influence from activist investors).
5. Key Takeaways
- Larger companies tend to have fewer candidates per seat (management’s nominees are rarely challenged).
- Smaller companies are more likely to see contested board elections.
- Board size decreases as company size decreases, with small-cap companies having 5-9 directors and large-cap companies having 9-15 directors.
- Elections are usually annual, but staggered boards spread elections over three years.
Business Entity Comparison with Examples
Feature | C-Corporation (C-Corp) | S-Corporation (S-Corp) | Limited Partnership (LP) | Limited Liability Company (LLC) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Legal Entity | Separate from owners | Separate from owners | Separate entity | Separate from owners |
Taxation | Double taxation (corporate + personal) | Pass-through to shareholders | Pass-through to partners | Usually pass-through, or elect corporate |
Owners | Shareholders | ≤ 100 U.S. shareholders | At least 1 general & 1+ limited partners | Members (no limit) |
Liability Protection | Yes — for shareholders | Yes — for shareholders | Limited for limited partners only | Yes — for all members |
Who Can Own | Anyone (including entities/foreigners) | Only U.S. individuals & certain trusts | Anyone | Anyone |
Shares Transferable? | Yes | Restricted | Usually restricted | Often restricted |
Management | Board of Directors & Officers | Board of Directors & Officers | General partner manages | Flexible: member or manager-managed |
Raising Capital | Easiest — public & private funding | Limited by shareholder rules | Moderate — common in private placements | Moderate — depends on structure |
Ideal For | Large companies, startups, IPOs | Small-to-mid-sized U.S. businesses | Private equity, real estate, hedge funds | Small-to-mid-sized businesses, real estate |
Common Examples | Apple, Microsoft, JPMorgan Chase | Local law firms, medical practices | Blackstone Real Estate Income Trust (BREIT), Oil & Gas partnerships | Real estate investment LLCs, family businesses |
Common Uses / Industries | Tech, banking, manufacturing | Professional services, small corporations | Investment funds, venture capital, real estate | Real estate, e-commerce, consulting, services |
Key Takeaways
-
C-Corporations (C-Corps)
C-Corps are ideal for large companies or startups seeking significant investment or planning to go public (IPO).
They offer unlimited shareholders, easy transfer of shares, and are attractive to institutional investors — but they come with double taxation (corporate and dividend level).
Commonly used in tech, finance, and manufacturing industries due to their growth needs and access to capital markets. -
S-Corporations (S-Corps)
S-Corps are suitable for small to mid-sized domestic businesses, like law firms, dental offices, or family businesses, that want pass-through taxation while still enjoying corporate liability protection.
They are limited to 100 U.S. individual shareholders and cannot be owned by entities, which makes them less flexible for expansion. -
Limited Partnerships (LPs)
LPs are favored by investment funds, real estate syndicates, and oil & gas ventures because they allow general partners to manage and limited partners to invest passively with limited liability.
This structure supports raising capital without giving up control, and provides pass-through tax treatment. -
Limited Liability Companies (LLCs)
LLCs are highly flexible and provide limited liability with fewer formalities.
They are popular among real estate investors, consultants, freelancers, and small business owners who want simple tax treatment and management structure, and the ability to choose how they’re taxed.
S-Corp vs. LLC – Key Distinctions and Why It Matters
Factor | S-Corporation (S-Corp) | Limited Liability Company (LLC) |
---|---|---|
Taxation | Default pass-through; profits/losses pass to shareholders, taxed on personal returns | Default pass-through, but can elect to be taxed as a C-Corp or S-Corp (flexible) |
Self-Employment Taxes | Owners can pay themselves a salary and avoid self-employment tax on remaining profits | All profits subject to self-employment tax unless taxed as S-Corp |
Ownership Restrictions | ≤ 100 U.S. individuals only; no entities, non-resident aliens, or multiple classes of stock | No restrictions — members can be individuals, entities, foreigners; multiple ownership classes allowed |
Formality Requirements | Requires Board of Directors, corporate bylaws, shareholder meetings, minutes | Less formal — no board or annual meetings required (unless state requires) |
Profit Distribution | Must distribute profits strictly based on ownership | Can allocate profits unevenly, regardless of ownership % |
Flexibility | Less flexible — designed to mirror a traditional corporation | Highly flexible — ideal for tailoring agreements among owners |
Ideal For | Businesses that want corporate structure with tax efficiency, or plan to draw salaries | Businesses needing flexibility in ownership, management, and profit sharing |
Choose an S-Corp if:
- You’re a small U.S.-based business with ≤ 100 shareholders.
- You want to save on self-employment taxes by paying yourself a reasonable salary.
- You’re okay with formal structure and equal profit sharing.
Choose an LLC if:
- You want maximum flexibility in ownership and profit allocation.
- You have foreign or entity owners or multiple classes of ownership.
- You want minimal corporate formalities and customizable agreements.
SEP IRA vs. SIMPLE IRA
Feature | SEP IRA | SIMPLE IRA |
---|---|---|
Full Name | Simplified Employee Pension IRA | Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees IRA |
Who Can Establish | Employers (including self-employed) | Employers with ≤ 100 employees |
Employee Contribution | Not allowed | Allowed (up to annual limit) |
Employer Contribution | Required, discretionary (can vary each year) | Required, non-discretionary (match or fixed 2%) |
Contribution Limits (2024) | Up to 25% of compensation or $69,000 max | Employee: $16,000 Employer: match up to 3% or 2% fixed |
Catch-Up Contribution (Age 50+) | Not allowed | Allowed – additional $3,500 |
Vesting | Immediate | Immediate |
Plan Administration | Simple – little paperwork | Simple – minimal filing |
Employee Eligibility | Must have earned $750+ in 3 of last 5 years | Earned $5,000 in any 2 preceding years and expects $5,000 this year |
Withdrawals Before 59½ | Tax + 10% penalty | Tax + 25% penalty if within 2 years of participation; 10% thereafter |
Ideal For | Self-employed or small businesses with variable income | Small employers seeking a straightforward plan with employee contributions |
Treasury Department Bureaus:
Bureau | What It Does |
---|---|
Internal Revenue Service (IRS) | Administers and enforces federal tax laws; collects federal taxes. |
Bureau of the Fiscal Service (BFS) | Manages the government’s accounting, central payment systems, and public debt. |
Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) | Regulates and supervises national banks and federal savings associations. |
Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) | Fights money laundering and terrorism financing through data collection and analysis. |
Bureau of Engraving and Printing (BEP) | Designs and prints U.S. paper currency and security documents. |
U.S. Mint | Produces coins and manages their distribution. |
Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB) | Regulates alcohol, tobacco, and firearms taxes and trade practices. |
Community Development Financial Institutions Fund (CDFI Fund) | Promotes economic opportunity via community development investments. |